From the Archives: Can Singing About the Gospel Become Rote?

One of the drums I will never tire of beating is this: All biblical worship is rooted in and made possible by the cross of Christ. In my experience, the contemporary church (and any church, for that matter) is always in danger of neglecting the gospel in its songs. I said it this way in my book, Worship Matters:

The gospel is not merely one of many possible themes we can touch on as we come to worship God. It is the central and foundational theme. All our worship originates and is brought into focus at the cross of Jesus Christ.

Glorying in Jesus Christ means glorying in his cross. That doesn’t mean looking at some icon or two pieces of wood nailed together. Nor does it imply that every song we sing has the word cross in it. It has little to do with church gatherings that are more like a funeral than a celebration.

The cross stands for all that was accomplished through the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus, the Son of God. It focuses on his substitutionary death at Calvary but includes everything that gave meaning to that act. His preexistent state in glory. His incarnation. His life of perfect obedience. His suffering. His resurrection. His ascension. His present intercession and reign in glory. His triumphant return.

I will always plead that worship pastors lead gospel-centered worship that is characterized by:

  • an awareness that the cross/gospel should be referenced somewhere in the time of singing.
  • viewing the gospel as our primary motivation for praising God.
  • helping people understand that only Jesus enables us to approach God – not music, musicians, worship leaders, or particular worship songs.
  • encouraging congregations to be most enthusiastic about the theme the Bible is the most enthusiastic about – the Lamb of God who was slain.

When the Gospel Loses Its Power
But over the years I’ve seen learned that this vital truth can be misapplied. We can practice gospel-centered corporate worship in a way that is more obligatory than faith-filled. What once magnified the glory of Christ becomes lifeless repetition. My friend, Jon Payne, shared some thoughts with me on this topic that I found helpful. He pointed out that a formulaic approach to gospel-centered worship can lead to some of the following problems:

  • thinking every song should be exclusively about justification, boldness before the throne, or our sins being completely forgiven.
  • thinking every song list should climax with a “gospel” song.
  • an inability to reference or articulate uniquely other aspects of the gospel – adoption, reconciliation, union with Christ, etc.
  • a scarcity of other themes in our songs such as the wisdom of God, the eternity of God, the power of God, the incarnation, the kingship of Christ, heaven.
  • worshiping a doctrine rather than allowing that doctrine to lead us to a living Savior. We are not “crowning the gospel with many crowns.”

Leading gospel-centered worship in a faithless way can lead to some bad fruit:

  • The gospel and the Savior lose glory in the eyes of bored worshipers.
  • People develop a limited view of God and his attributes.
  • People don’t learn how to apply the gospel to other areas of life/Biblical themes.
  • The gospel becomes a crude, repetitive statement of facts rather than a lens through which we view all of life.
  • We think an explicit reference to the gospel makes our worship acceptable, rather than trust in a crucified and risen Savior.
  • Rather than expecting to encounter God because of the gospel people come expecting to repeat faithless facts.

It’s our responsibility as leaders to make sure, as the Puritans said, that we always “labor to be affected by the cross.” The gospel of Jesus Christ is the greatest news the world has ever heard and our singing should show it.

What have you done to make sure that singing about Christ’s redemptive work on the cross never becomes rote?

[originally posted Jan. 29, 2010]

9 Responses to From the Archives: Can Singing About the Gospel Become Rote?

  1. Ben May 30, 2012 at 7:37 PM #

    Observation of the historical church liturgical calendar has been a great way for us to be sure we’re incorporating a full palette of themes into our worship services. A byproduct of singing songs geared toward each of these specific Sundays or seasons is that we end up bringing songs into the church’s repertoire for the rest of the year which we may not have sung otherwise. For example, we sings more songs about the Holy Spirit during the whole year because we introduce a new Holy Spirit-themed song each year at Pentecost.

  2. Gangai Victor June 6, 2012 at 5:42 AM #

    “The gospel becomes a crude, repetitive statement of facts rather than a lens through which we view all of life.”

    Wow, that’s deep!

  3. Jami Lynn June 25, 2012 at 6:42 PM #

    I’ve found that a Lead Worshipper, leading from a heart that is truly captivated by Christ and in awe of the Cross, leads in this way authentically. When the Leader’s focus is more on the people he/she is leading than on the One they are leading those people to, that’s where the pit falls occur. Thanks for pointing this out. It will help me out a lot.

  4. churches in Oakville July 20, 2012 at 8:53 AM #

    We should sing not just to be heard but to touch lives.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Can Singing About the Gospel Become Rote? | Effectual Grace - May 25, 2012

    [...] Singing About the Gospel Become Rote? Posted on May 25, 2012 by John Samson From his blog, Bob Kauflin [...]

  2. Singing the Gospel « SODEGLO - May 26, 2012

    [...] From the Archives: Can Singing About the Gospel Become Rote?. Rate this:Share this:EmailFacebookTwitterLike this:LikeBe the first to like this post. [...]

  3. What should a ministers library look like? … and a few other ideas! | Evangelicals Now - June 8, 2012

    [...] Bob Kauflin – Can singing about the Gospel become rote? Share this:MoreLike this:LikeBe the first to like this post. This entry was posted in Links worth a look and tagged church, pastoral work, prayers, religion, sanctification, winning souls by Evangelicals Now. Bookmark the permalink. [...]

  4. Food For Thought Thursday: 6/28 « True Satisfaction - June 28, 2012

    [...] Can Singing About the Gospel Become Rote? – Bob Kauflin outlines what our worship services should be filled with, namely, exaltation of the King of kings and Lord of lords. May we be forever tied to our Savior Jesus Christ and may our singing reflect His glory rather than the accurate pictures of doctrine that represent Him. Kauflin warns that giving sole attention to singing about the doctrine of the gospel  while ignoring other facets of God can lead to mundane and faithless worship. In Kauflin’s words, “we are not crowning the gospel with many crowns.” Sing about Jesus, our Savior King. [...]

  5. Weekend Link List « Thinking Out Loud - June 30, 2012

    [...] Also of worship interest: Gospel-driven worship can become obligatory when in fact, songs can be used to drive various points and aspects of both God’s nature and Christian experience. Bob Kauflin reposts some great advice. [...]

Leave a Reply

Powered by WordPress. Designed by Woo Themes